Vegetarianism and Christianity — are they compatible ? Keith Akers

, par Estela Torres

Vegetarianism and Christianity — are they compatible ? http://www.compassionatespirit.com/wpblog/2017/01/09/vegetarianism-and-christianity-are-they-compatible/
Keith Akers

Is vegetarianism part of Christianity, or are they incompatible ? Christianity and vegetarianism don’t have to be in competition, but in practice they are. While many become vegetarians for health reasons, the heart of vegetarianism is its ethical component — the practice of not eating meat out of concern for the suffering of animals.

People who become vegetarians often speak of their “conversion” to vegetarianism, precisely because of this ethical component in their dietary practice. They come to realize that animals have feelings and that we should not kill them unnecessarily. Communicating this ethical concern to the outside world, though, is often difficult. Christian vegetarians find themselves in the odd position of sharing a central part of their lives with the Buddhist, or Jewish, or secular vegetarian, that they don’t share with their own religious community.

Christianity, beginning with Paul, has largely rejected the idea that it is wrong to eat meat, and regarded ethical vegetarianism as a competing idea. If I, as a Christian, become vegetarian because I feel it is wrong to kill animals or eat meat, what incentive do I have to continue supporting a Christian community which, at best, is going to have grudging tolerance for my vegetarianism, and at worst, will be actively hostile to an ethical precept which is central to my life ?
©Isa Leshko

Early Christian Vegetarians

It was not always this way. Early church writers such as Jerome, Basil the Great, Origen, Tertullian, and Clement of Alexandria were all vegetarians ; all the apostles abstained from meat and wine (Eusebius, Proof of the Gospel 3.5), and vegetarians were “without number” in the early church (St. Augustine, Of the Morals of the Catholic Church 33).

Paul’s influence against vegetarianism

Motivation is critical here. Ethical vegetarianism is the very first heresy, and Paul’s words have been quoted ever since then against “heretical” vegetarians : “the weak man [weak in faith, that is] eats only vegetables” (Romans 14:2). St. Augustine condemned the vegetarian Manicheans, and in the Middle Ages the Albigensian crusade specifically targeted vegetarians ; suspected heretics would be given an animal to kill, and if they refused, they were judged to be heretics.

The example of Jesus is critical here. If Jesus ate meat, then while we are not obligated to eat meat, it cannot be wrong to eat meat. And this means that ethical vegetarianism — the idea that eating meat is wrong — is a heresy. Is there a way to avoid this conflict ?

Both sides in this dispute seem to have influenced the writing of the gospels. Jesus distributes bread and fish to the multitudes, or even eats fish ; but Jesus also advocates kindness to animals and attacks the animal sacrifice business in the temple.

We can gain some insight by going back to the original controversy concerning ethical vegetarianism described in Paul’s letters, which are decades earlier than any of the gospels. Paul is in a dispute with vegetarians in the early church and believes that it is perfectly all right to eat meat.

Eat whatever is sold in the meat market without raising any question on the ground of conscience. (I Corinthians 10:25)

At the same time Paul counsels diplomacy in dealing with the vegetarians who think otherwise, and taking care not to offend them :
I [Paul] will never eat meat, lest I cause my brother to fall. (I Corinthians 8:13)
It is right not to eat meat or drink wine or do anything that makes your brother stumble (Romans 14:21).

Jesus and James were vegetarians

This controversy makes no sense at all unless Jesus was a vegetarian. At the time that Paul wrote, many were still alive who had known the earthly Jesus, including James, Peter, and the other apostles and disciples. If Jesus had eaten meat, all Paul would have had to say was “it cannot be wrong to eat meat, since Christ himself ate meat.” But he doesn’t say this. In fact, to keep the peace, he becomes vegetarian himself. Why ? Undoubtedly because it was well known that Jesus was a vegetarian, just like the apostles and James his brother.

The early Christian vegetarians that Paul talked about clearly were offended by the thought that other believers might sacrifice animals or eat meat ; they believed that all followers of Jesus should be vegetarians. So who are these trouble-making vegetarians who must not be offended ? Comparing the disputes over vegetarianism and animal sacrifice in Romans 14 and I Corinthians 8–10 with the murky food dispute in Galatians 2, it appears that these trouble-making vegetarians were the leaders of the early church — James, Peter, and John.

Paul interpreted the controversy over vegetarianism and animal sacrifice as being about Jewish laws or traditions. But the Jewish Christians — those early Christians who followed both Jesus and the Jewish law, as interpreted by Jesus — rejected this explanation. For the Jewish Christians, Jesus himself was a vegetarian and opposed animal sacrifice. God never wanted animals to be killed and so did not order the animal sacrifices (Homilies 3.45). The Jewish Christians were just as much against the Jewish orthodoxy that sacrificed animals in the temple, as they were against the emerging Christian orthodoxy which counseled that we eat anything sold in the meat market without raising questions of conscience.

James the brother of Jesus, the first leader of the Jerusalem church after Jesus’ departure, was universally acknowledged to be a strict vegetarian, and in fact was raised as a vegetarian (Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 2.23.5–6). Why would Jesus’ family raise James as a vegetarian, but not Jesus ? The natural conclusion is that Jesus’ parents raised Jesus and James as vegetarians and that this was part of the original gospel message.

St James

Later Jewish Christianity assumed that the vegetarian James was not just speaking for the church, but passing on the teaching of Jesus and the original Jerusalem church. In the gospel of the (Jewish Christian) Ebionites, Jesus indignantly rejects the Passover meat, teaches vegetarianism, and attacks animal sacrifice, saying “I have come to destroy the sacrifices, and unless you stop sacrificing [animals], my wrath will not cease against you” (Epiphanius, Panarion 30).
Jesus attacks Animal Sacrifices in the Temple

If Jesus had compassion for animals as part of his message, then that would explain why Jesus went into the temple and attacked what he found there.
In the temple he found those who were selling oxen and sheep and pigeons, and the money-changers at their business. And making a whip of cords, he drove them all, with the sheep and oxen, out of the temple ; and he poured out the coins of the money-changers and overturned their tables. And he told those who sold the pigeons, “Take these things away ; you shall not make my Father’s house a house of trade.” (John 2:14–16 ; parallels in Matthew 21:12–13, Mark 11:15–17, and Luke 19:45–46)

The animals which are being sold are sacrificial animals, and it is these dealers in animals whom Jesus attacked — chasing out the animals to be sacrificed, as well as those who were buying or selling them to be sacrificed. “Cleansing the temple” was an act of animal liberation. Jesus himself twice quoted the prophets when he said, “I desire mercy, not sacrifice” (Matthew 9:13, 12:7, quoting Hosea 6:6).

A Gospel Message for ALL Creation

Jesus was arrested and executed after a confrontation in the temple in which he disrupted the bloody animal sacrifice business. If Christianity is to become truly universal, it must come to grips with this all-inclusive tradition of kindness which stands at the very beginning of Christian history. The simplest solution is to make vegetarianism part of the gospel message. The good news is not just for humans, but for all creation.

  • Saint Hubert, Patron de la Chasse ? :

    Tous les ans à cette époque, les veneurs (chasseurs à courre) organisent une MESSE pour faire bénir leur meute et célébrer leur loisir.
    C’est l’occasion pour tous les opposants à cette pratique brutale et cruelle de se rassembler, encore et encore, chaque année, jusqu’à qu’elle cesse. Et la question (...)

  • Vegetarianism and Christianity — are they compatible ? Keith Akers

    Vegetarianism and Christianity — are they compatible ? http://www.compassionatespirit.com/wpblog/2017/01/09/vegetarianism-and-christianity-are-they-compatible/ Keith Akers
    Is vegetarianism part of Christianity, or are they incompatible ? Christianity and vegetarianism don’t have to be in (...)

  • Parution du livre Coup Fatal par Elisabeth Hardouin-Fugier

    LE COUP FATAL par Élisabeth Hardouin-Fugier https://www.alma-editeur.fr/le_coup_fatal.html À PROPOS DU LIVRE Les mauvais traitements subis par les animaux ont sensibilisé l’opinion au problème du fonctionnement des abattoirs. Du paléolithique jusqu’à nos jours, voici la première histoire économique (...)

  • 98 Important Facts about Animal Cruelty

    98 Important Facts about Animal Cruelty By Karin Lehnardt, Senior Writer Published February 20, 2017 https://www.factretriever.com/animal-cruelty-facts
    To make a 40-inch fur coat it takes between 30 and 200 chinchilla or 60 mink, 50 sables, 50 muskrats, 45 opossums, 40 raccoons, 35 rabbits, (...)

  • Comment adhérer ? Pourquoi adhérer ?

    ADHÉSION Pourquoi adhérer ? Pour montrer que la communauté chrétienne se préoccupe du vivant, qu’elle réfute toute forme d’exploitation, de violence et de souffrance infligée à un être vivant, qu’elle est solidaire de toute la création.
    Pour montrer par le nombre d’adhérents que les chrétiens aujourd’hui (...)

  • L’ANTHROPO­CENTRISME DU CHRISTIANISME OCCIDENTAL, Eric Baratay

    Collège Sismondi Cours d’OC – Une brève histoire des animaux AC – 2007-2008 https://old-base.sismondi.ch/animaux-2/base-documentaire/textes/Cyrulnik1998/Baratay-Christianisme.odt/view Éric Baratay
    L’ANTHROPO­CENTRISME DU CHRISTIANISME OCCIDENTAL
    L’ANIMAL DANS L’ANCIEN TESTAMENT
    Religion révélée, le (...)

  • La charte du prêtre et du chrétien, ami des animaux

    Il est en émerveillement devant la Création et toutes les Créatures de Dieu.

    Il souhaite vivre en harmonie avec tout le Créé, et particulièrement les animaux, suivant l’exemple de St François d’Assise, St Philippe Néri et St Martin de Porres.

    Il est animé de la compassion et de l’Amour du Christ pour toute la Création.

    Il dénonce sans relâche toute exploitation abusive de l’animal. Pour lui, l’animal n’étant pas une simple denrée alimentaire, il n’entre pas dans l’esprit de (...)

  • L’âme des animaux - Jean Nakos

    Article reproduit du blog de Jean Nakos - Le Christianisme et les animaux
    [NDLR : Cet article est basé sur le chapitre "L’âme des animaux" de l’opuscule de Jean Nakos "Plaidoyer pour une Théologie de l’animal" (épuisé), Lyon 2001. Copyright : Jean Nakos, 2001]
    Qu’est-ce que l’âme ? De Platon et (...)

  • Douceur et violence - André Wénin

    André Wénin Université catholique de Louvain
    Douceur et violence : la nourriture végétale et carnée en Genèse 1-9
    La plupart d’entre nous mangent de la viande tous les jours, sans se poser de questions. D’autres ne mangent qu’une nourriture végétale, ce sont les végétariens. Pourquoi ne mangent-ils pas (...)

  • Premier sermon sur le respect de la vie, Albert Schweitzer

    XV Premier sermon sur le Respect de la Vie, prononcé le dimanche 16 février 1919, à l’église Saint-Nicolas à Strasbourg.
    Un des scribes qui les avait entendus discuter, voyant que Jésus avait bien répondu aux Sadducéens, s’approcha de lui et demanda : « Quel est le premier de tous les comman­dements ? (...)

  • Minding Animals Conference Mexico City

    http://www.mindinganimals.com/about-contact/objectives/
    Minding Animals International Incorporated (MAI) provides an avenue for the transdisciplinary field of Animal Studies to be more responsive to the protection of animals. It is recognised that animal protection in this context (...)

  • Documentaires/ Films

    Documentaires/ Films
    À regarder et à diffuser To watch and share
    Peaceable kingdom
    http://www.tribeofheart.org/hb/pkannounce.htm http://www.tribeofheart.org/sr/pkj_french.htm
    Santa Fiesta http://santafiesta.es/about
    Earthlings https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-Is7ZcacOU
    What the health (...)

  • Créez un refuge pour libérer vos terrains de la chasse-ASPAS

    Grâce au superbe travail de ASPAS (Association pour la protection des animaux sauvages Madline Reynaud, Marc Giraud) tous les propriétaires ont le DROIT de sanctuariser leurs terrains pour qu’ils soient des havres de paix pour #animaux, faune flore milieux naturels ET humains ! (...)